Shipping Australia

Advocating Shipping Policy, Sustainability & Safety

We Know Shipping. The major focus of Shipping Australia, as a peak industry body, is both to promote and advance the interests of shipowners and shipping agents in all matters of shipping policy, environmentally sustainable practices and safe ship operations.
  • Policy Council Login
  • Home
  • News & Info
    • Media Releases
    • Events
    • Magazines
    • Photo Gallery
    • Publications
    • Membership
    • Members’ Area
      • Login
    • Factsheets
      • Current Factsheets
      • Fact Sheets 1991 to 1999
    • Industry Links
    • Maritime History
  • Covid-19
  • Courses & Careers
    • On-line Courses
      • Introduction to Shipping
      • Chain of Responsibility
      • Fundamentals of the Maritime Industry
      • Reefer Cargo Handling
    • Courses
    • Careers In Shipping
    • Education
    • Job Vacancies
  • About SAL
    • List of Full Members
    • List of Associate Members
    • Role of SAL
    • Board of Directors
    • Policy Council
    • Steering Groups (National)
    • Committees (State)
    • Young Shipping Australia (YSA)
      • YSA – New South Wales
      • YSA – Victoria
    • Policies
  • Liner Shipping
    • Celebrating the shipping container that changed the world – 50 years of international container shipping for Australia
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us
  • FAQ
    • Standards on Empty Shipping Container Inspection (v2 document, May 2021)
    • Container Hire and Late Return/Detention Charges
    • Food Quality Containers
    • Terminal Access Charges – who should pay?

ACCC appeals Federal Court’s container terminal decision

July 30, 2021 by Shipping Australia

Photo credit: Succo via Pixabay

Australia’s competition watchdog is appealing against the decision of the Federal Court in the NSW container terminal competition case.

At the time of privatisation of the ports of Newcastle, Botany and Kembla, the State Government had agreed for 50 years to compensate the operator of Port Botany & Port Kembla if container traffic at the soon-to-be rival Port of Newcastle rose above a certain threshold. The agreement was contained in documents known as “Port Commitment Deeds”.

Another deed, signed when the Port of Newcastle was privatised, required the Port of Newcastle to reimburse the State of NSW for any compensation paid to the operators of Port Botany / Port Kembla. The compensation that would be paid by the NSW government to NSW Ports would be equivalent to the wharfage fee that NSW Ports would receive as if it had handled the containers. The ACCC reports that no payments have yet been made as the container threshold at Newcastle has not yet been reached.

Derivative crown immunity

On 29 June this year, in the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v NSW Ports, the Court ruled that competition laws did not apply to port operator NSW Ports because it enjoyed “derivative crown immunity”.

Australian federal, state and territory governments have immunity from some laws under specific conditions. That immunity can extend to non-government entities in certain circumstances.

According to the ACCC, crown immunity protects state governments from competition laws when those governments are not carrying on a business.

The ACCC is appealing against the finding that competition law did not apply because the State was not carrying on a business when it entered into the Port Commitment Deeds. The competition watchdog is also appealing against the finding that NSW Ports benefited from derivative Crown immunity.

Effects on competition

Secondly, the Federal court ruled that the compensation provisions in the Port Commitment Deeds did not have an anti-competitive purpose or effect.

ACCC Chair Rod Sims commented: “we are appealing from this decision because we consider that the purpose and likely effect of the compensation provisions entered into at the time the State of NSW privatised the Ports of Botany and Kembla was anti-competitive.

“Agreements entered into when existing State-owned monopoly businesses are being privatised, which seek to maximise profit from the sale by protecting that monopoly from competition in the future, are inherently anti-competitive.

“We remain concerned that the Port Commitment Deeds will effectively hinder or prevent the development of a competing container terminal at the Port of Newcastle for 50 years. This is a matter of significance for the Australian economy,” Mr Sims said.

Further reading:

The full statement from the ACCC can be read online here.

Statements from both NSW Ports and the Port of Newcastle in reaction to the Federal Court decision can be read here.

The decision of the Federal Court in ACCC v NSW Ports (2021) can be read here.

Filed Under: Media Releases, Members, Policy Council Tagged With: ACCC, Container ports, Container terminals, Federal Court, NSW Ports

Sign up to our Signal Newsletter

By clicking subscribe you agree to our privacy policy and to receive our email correspondence from which you may unsubscribe at any time

Subscribe

Subscribe to Sal Magazine

Become a Shipping Australia Member

Shipping Australia Ltd provides professional support to its members through promoting member interests. Membership is open to all ship owners, operators and agents both Australian and International providing services to or within Australia.

Become a Member

Accepted Payment Methods

Shipping Australia Full Members

  • A.P. Moller-Maersk A/S
  • Asiaworld Shipping Services Pty Ltd
  • Austral Asia Line Pte Ltd
  • BBC Chartering
  • CMA CGM Group Agencies (Australia & New Zealand) Pty Ltd
  • Engage Marine
  • Evergreen Marine Australia Pty Ltd
  • Gulf Agency Company (Australia) Pty Ltd
  • Hamburg Sud Australia Pty Ltd
  • Hapag-Lloyd Australia Pty Ltd
  • HMM Australia Pty Ltd
  • Inchcape Shipping Services
  • K Line (Australia) Pty Ltd
  • LBH Australia Pty Ltd
  • Leeward Group
  • Mediterranean Shipping Co (Aust) Pty Ltd
  • MOL Shipping Australia PTY LTD
  • Monson Agencies Australia Pty Ltd
  • Neptune Pacific Agency Australia P/L
  • NYK Australia Pty Ltd
  • Ocean Network Express (Australia) Pty Ltd
  • Oldendorff Carriers
  • OOCL (Australia) Pty Ltd
  • Pacific Asia Express Pty Ltd
  • Seaway Agencies Pty Ltd
  • Ship Agency Services Pty Ltd
  • Svitzer Australia Pty Ltd
  • Swire Shipping Pte. Ltd
  • Wallenius Wilhelmsen Ocean AS
  • Wilhelmsen Ships Service

View All

Copyright © 2022 · Shipping Australia · Site by Love Communications

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use